Welcome to Consumer Reports Advocacy

For 85 years CR has worked for laws and policies that put consumers first. Learn more about CR’s work with policymakers, companies, and consumers to help build a fair and just marketplace at TrustCR.org

FDA’s proposal on animal feed leaves nation vulnerable to mad cow

October 4, 2005

Consumers Union says FDA proposed restriction on animal feed leaves nation vulnerable to spread of Mad Cow Disease

FDA’s proposal to require feed mills to eliminate 30-month-old cattle’s brains and spinal cords from animal feed leaves the nation vulnerable to the spread of mad cow disease in the United States, according to Consumers Union, publisher of Consumer Reports magazine.
The new FDA rule would still allow the brains of younger cattle, as well as the rest of the carcass, to be fed to pigs and chickens, and pigs and chickens to be fed to cows. Cow blood could still also be fed to calves as milk replacer. The FDA said it was banning these dangerous materials in January 2004 but never acted on its promise.
“We shouldn’t wait for a major outbreak of mad cow disease to take preventive action. There is no question that we should not be feeding the remains of any mammals to food animals, and by not closing this dangerous loophole, we are exposing the American public to unnecessary risk,” says Michael Hansen, Ph.D., a biologist with Consumers Union.
“The United Kingdom took many halfway steps in their efforts to eliminate mad cow disease and failed to stop it. Only when the UK stopped feeding all mammal material to any food animal, did they succeed in getting the number of mad cow cases down to less than ten a year,” adds Hansen.
The United States has identified two cases of mad cow disease, one in a cow imported from Canada, and the second in a cow that lived its whole life in Texas. Five cases have been identified in Canada. The US reopened its border to Canadian beef and live animals under 30 months of age in July 2005.
“Thirty months is not a magic safe number,” says Michael Hansen. “In Japan, two of the twenty cases of mad cow disease that they have identified were under 30 months. We have such a small surveillance program in the United States—only 1 percent of cows are tested at slaughter, and the USDA is talking about cutting that back tenfold—that an infected animal could easily slip through and get into the food or feed chain. Once there, one infected animal could infect thousands of others.”
# # #

Michael Hansen, 914-378-2452 (work), 917-774-3801 (cell)
Jean Halloran, 914-378-2457 (work)
Jen Shecter, 914-378-2402 (work)